Using European plant and dairy waste as an alternative to soy-based animal feed could see a big drop in agricultural emissions and prevent deforestation.
Every year around a third of all food produced for human consumption is wasted, according to the United Nations. That equates to 1.3 billion tonnes of food down the drain and huge amounts of avoidable greenhouse gas emissions.
'Food loss and waste also amount to a major squandering of resources including water, land, energy, labour and capital,' said Professor Montse Jorba Rafart, an expert in agrifood technologies from Leitat, a Spanish technological centre.
Instead, this waste could become a sustainable solution for another resource-heavy agricultural sector – animal feed.
Prof. Jorba coordinated the NOSHAN project where researchers from seven European countries investigated turning fruit, vegetable, cereal and dairy waste into pork and poultry feed. They found the most nutrient-rich sources of waste came from pumpkins, rapeseed, cheese and yoghurt production, barley, mushrooms and olives.
This could take a climate-friendly chunk out of livestock's environmental impact. Currently, a third of total farmland is used to grow animal food, while producing, processing and transporting this feed contributes to about 45% of the sector's emissions.
Prof. Jorba says that substituting a portion of existing chicken feed for their food-waste-based product could help cut the carbon footprint of the meat.
'For every kilogram of (chicken) broiler feed, carbon dioxide emissions are reduced by 300 grams with a 10% NOSHAN mix diet,' said Prof. Jorba. 'Assuming 10% of total broiler feed can be switched to 10% NOSHAN mix, this means a total avoidance of 6.2 million tons of CO2 emissions to the atmosphere each year.'
NOSHAN's business partners are currently looking to turn their research into a product and hope to commercialise it in two to three years.
Big CO2 savings could also be expected with their feed for pigs, while cattle, sheep and goat feed is an avenue that researchers could explore in the future.
If a similar approach expanded to the global livestock sector, Prof. Jorba estimates a reduction of natural land transformation by 30% and agricultural land occupation by 12%, which would protect carbon sinks and prevent greenhouse gas emissions from the additional intensive agriculture.
Many European farmers rely on importing soy-based animal feed, but these products often contribute to deforestation in places like the Amazon in Brazil and Chaco in Argentina.
Although NOSHAN's products cannot completely replace this animal feed they can still relieve pressure from soy-based feed and diminish the sector’s environmental impacts. The operation is also more energy-efficient than conventional feed production, which means another cut in livestock's carbon footprint.
'By reducing the amount of raw materials, such as soybean, used for the piglet and broiler diets, NOSHAN decreases the soy dependency of European feed industry,' said Prof. Jorba. 'Obtaining feed ingredients from natural (waste) sources could also reduce the cost of feed (for farmers).'
Along with animal feed, many European farmers are dependent on imported fertilisers to ensure their land has the right soil conditions to grow crops productively. However, these products come from unsustainable sources with their own set of environmental impacts.
To produce synthetic, or factory-made, fertilisers, a huge amount of fossil fuel is required. Mineral fertilisers, like phosphate, are brought in from huge mining operations in Morocco and China where, according to Professor Siegfried Vlaeminck, an environmental engineer from University of Antwerp in Belgium, supplies are running low.
'In 50 to 100 years we may run out of the readily accessible phosphate,' he said. 'Nonetheless, phosphorus is irreplaceable as a fertilising element to sustain crop growth yields.'
If no alternative is found, then these energy-intensive industries could look to start new mines elsewhere and spread their environmental impact to other regions. It also means EU's animal farming remains dependent on finite resources, but there is a largely untapped solution much closer to home – and in plentiful supply.
'We have massive amounts of animal waste in Europe, due to the fact that we have a lot of intensive livestock farming,' said Prof. Vlaeminck, who was also the coordinator of ManureEcoMine, a project that aimed to refine nutrient-rich animal manure into green fertilisers.
The project estimated that European pigs and cows jointly produce 1.27 billion tonnes of manure per year, enough to fill more than 500 000 Olympic-sized swimming pools. Currently, this manure is either sprayed inefficiently on farmland or undergoes low-grade processing, both of which have negative environmental impacts.
Instead, ManureEcoMine came up with a biorefinery that processes manure from different animals, extracts key nutrients, and upgrades them into green fertilisers. These can be custom-made for different farms depending on the needs of a crop or the soil.
'We have massive amounts of animal waste in Europe, due to the fact that we have a lot of intensive livestock farming.'
Prof. Siegfried Vlaeminck, University of Antwerp, Belgium
The researchers are now looking for funding to scale up the approach, but Prof. Vlaeminck says farmers are too reliant on synthetic fertilisers and 'need to be convinced to switch' to more sustainable alternatives.
To help sway them, the project estimated that by switching to green fertiliser, European farmers could cut €4.5 billion from the current annual €15.5 billion bill for synthetic fertilisers. ManureEcoMine's approach would also redirect this cash back into local economies.
Still, this business model is based on an intensive livestock system, which itself has significant environmental impacts, but unless or until everyone stops eating meat, the sector needs sustainable innovation.
'We need to find a solution for the massive amount of manure today. If we are serious about leveraging sustainability on a large scale, manure is definitely one of the hotspots to work with,' said Prof. Vlaeminck.
All research in this article is funded by the EU. If you liked this article, please consider sharing it on social media.
The coronavirus pandemic disrupted the global food system and emphasised its structural inequity – from unequal food distribution to workers in the system going hungry. Experts are calling for a reimagining of the way we produce and distribute food so that everyone can access quality food. Despite producing more food by volume than humanity has to date, millions of people remain food insecure. Agriculture is also a major contributor to environmental degradation and climate change.
The pandemic left a visible imprint on car, bus and bicycle use – and at its height brought about cleaner city air – but it also disrupted another, less obvious but highly polluting sector: freight transport. Coronavirus plunged millions of planes, trucks, trains and ships into a massive experiment, disrupting supply chains as national borders closed and industries shut down. Researchers and industry are now looking to see if any of the changes will stick.
Leuven, Belgium, has been named the 2020 European Capital of Innovation for its use of innovation to improve residents’ lives.
The world’s pressing need is a vaccine to fight the current threat of Covid-19, but ultimately we may be able to develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine, Sunetra Gupta, a professor of theoretical epidemiology at the University of Oxford, UK, said at the European Commission’s annual research event.
'Frontier research' scientists share how they are fighting Covid-19.
The Belgian city won the €1 million iCapital cash prize, while runner-up prizes went to Cluj-Napoca, Espoo, Helsingborg, Vienna and Valencia.
Dr Kate Rychert studies ocean plate structures.